HOME

NEWS

STATE BRIEFS

LETTERS

KEY LEGISLATION

CONTACT US


COLUMNISTS

Marcia Barlow: Families

Bruce Barton: Borders


Carroll Cox: Rural Arizona

Dennis Durband: Culture War
 
Rick Erickson: Military

Bob Hugeri: From the Sidelines

Tom Jenney: Economics

Jane Jimenez: From the Home Front

Sandra Miller: Borders

John Semmens: Semi-News

 

 

 

DENNIS DURBAND

Sympathy Fest Among Phoenix Media Likely to End Soon

By Dennis Durband
July 31, 2007

So far, we have seen sympathy and exchanges of affection between the members of Phoenix TV stations 3 and 15 in the aftermath of their members killed in the July 27th helicopter crash. Once we get past memorial and funeral services and the lawyers take over, that is likely to end.

Grief often gives way to anger.

Already, Steve Chealander of the National Transportation Safety Board and eyewitnesses have alleged that Channel 15 chopper pilot Craig Smith caused the accident that took the lives of the two men aboard the Channel 3 helicopter and his Channel 15 colleague Rick Krolak. They’ve said it appears that Smith initiated contact with the stationary Channel 3 chopper. Channel 3 pilot Scott Bowerbank may be complicit as well for “parking” too close to Channel 15. Whatever happens, public sentiment will likely zero in on Christopher Jones, who led police on that chase, rather than placing judgment at the feet of any of the nice guy pilots.

In about nine months, the NTSB will issue a final report likely to implicate who was at fault in the accident. In the long months until then, new and old media alike will speculate on the causes. Accusations and emotions running on high heat cause boilovers. The love fest between stations may give way to tempers, tensions and defensiveness. On Monday, Channel 3 anchor Patti Kirkpatrick already displayed defensiveness regarding talk radio chatter on the tragedy. Today, a Channel 15 staff report referred to the accident as a mid-air “collision.” A Channel 3 report claims their own crew of Cox and Bowerbank “were killed Friday when the NewsChopper 3 helicopter collided with Channel 15’s helicopter while covering a chase in downtown Phoenix.” One would expect the stations’ respective lawyers to start reviewing such stories before posting on the Internet. Careless posts could be used as exhibits in future court proceedings.

KFYI Radio, Phoenix, ran a report today speculating on the cause of the accident. These questions, along with debate, will not only persist, but will likely intensify.

A helicopter is a very expensive piece of equipment. Talented pilots and journalists are valuable assets. Human lives are invaluable. Channels 3 and 15 will have to pay through the nose the next time they are in position to insure helicopters. Somebody is going to have to pay. The attorneys will certainly get their share of the millions awarded by the courts in the years to come. Lawyers are probably foaming at the mouth to catch this gravy train.

Christopher Jones, the 23-year-old man who led Phoenix police on a tepid, low-speed auto chase below the dense pack of news helicopters that awful day, is not going to be a source of money for the survivors and the TV stations looking for compensation. Attorneys may or may not even agree to implicate him in the fatalities. It appears to be a stretch to say that Jones “caused” the accident when news organizations, pilots and photographers made voluntary decisions to go airborne in search of street mayhem. The lawyers can only take aim at the TV stations to get any money for their clients.

All four of the men who died are said to have been great guys. When one of the two pilots is blamed for the catastrophe, it is not going to sit well. The victims are going to be angered when the helicopter accident is put into context by the NTSB. The community may well be divided as well.

Tensions, rumors, innuendo and anger may flare up long before the NTSB issues its report. Things could get ugly. You can bet the Phoenix New Times’ investigative reporters are working in overdrive on this story right now.

Channel 15 Report: Valley remembers 3TV chopper crash victims

Channel 3 Report: Valley to say good-bye to 3TV pilot, photographer


Dennis Durband is publisher and editor of The Arizona Conservative, is also a freelance writer and webmaster and a longtime journalist.

Home |News |State Briefs |Editorials|Letters |Key Legislation |Privacy Policy |Contact Us