HOME

NEWS

STATE BRIEFS

LETTERS

KEY LEGISLATION

CONTACT US

 


COLUMNISTS

Marcia Barlow: Families

Bruce Barton: Borders


Carroll Cox: Rural Arizona

Dennis Durband: Culture War
 
Rick Erickson: Military

Bob Hugeri: From the Sidelines

Tom Jenney: Economics

Jane Jimenez: From the Home Front

Sandra Miller: Borders

John Semmens: Semi-News


 

 

 

GUEST OPINION

Rep. Pearce Demands Action on Social, Economic Impact of Border Invasion

By State Rep. Russell Pearce (Republican-Mesa)
October 17, 2005

We the citizens of Arizona demand immediate action on the following steps to halt the terrible social and economic impact of illegal immigration: We ask the governor to:

1) Declare a real state of emergency in the State of Arizona, the first thing in a state of emergency is you call out the National Guard and send DPS to the border.

2) Issue an Emergency Executive Order reversing all written and de facto Sanctuary policies throughout the state (demand local law enforcement enforce the laws).

3) Issue an Emergency Executive Order designating sports arenas and other facilities as overflow holding areas for illegal aliens awaiting hearings and deportations (ending dangerous catch-and-release policies), build a "Tent City" if necessary.

4) Establish and impose financial and other personnel sanctions against State agencies and employees who conduct State business in languages other than Arizona Constitutionally designated Official English.

5) Deny or revoke state licenses, grants to any employer who knowingly hires illegal aliens.

We ask that you uphold your oath of office and take these steps without delay.

The failures of the current policies are so evident and oft-repeated that it is time act and to look forward.

What a massive failure of government, like Hurricane Katrina, the failure is at all levels, federal, state and local.

The cost is in billions of dollars (nationally):

*$70 billion in federal public benefits.

*$200 billion annually I lost American wages.

*1/3 of our federal prisoners are illegals (cost $1.6 billion).

*$1.6 billion in displaced American workers.

*$80 billion in the war on drugs.

*$8000 per student plus 1200 additional for English Learners in K-12 (times 1.5 million).

*$27 billion to provide forms, ballots, interpreters and brochures for languages other than English.

*$350 billion in unpaid taxes due to the underground workforce.

 *$2 to 3 billion in "child earned income tax credit" welfare for the working poor in addition to other welfare programs.

*$40.2 billion, business deductions for wage and benefits tax deductions

Today, conditions are probably as bad or worse than they ever have been on the border. What we find is a mass migration of historic proportions: individuals running through backyards, breaking down fences, slaughtering cattle, cutting their dogs' throats if they bark, and terrifying people. Men and women who live on the border walk around armed.  Women accompany their children to the bus stop with a gun in their purse in the heaviest cross-corridors.
 

We find that people are afraid to go out at night. Husbands and wives can't go out together unless somebody is home because someone may break-in and tear the place up.  Water tanks are emptied. Stock gets killed. Fences are destroyed. It's a very, very negative situation for people in the rural countryside.

Talking about illegal immigration is not polite: it just simply is not polite in society. 

5 Myths of illegal immigration:

  • Myth #1:  Illegal aliens take jobs Americans won’t do.

You pay an American a decent wage and they will do the job.  18 million Americans in unemployment lines, over 60 percent of adult black males are out of work (between ages of 18 & 24), and a bloated welfare system.

  • Myth #2:  Illegal aliens contribute more to the economy and tax base than they take.

Barrons report $311-350 in unpaid taxes due to the underground workforce.  A great majority of illegals make $6 to $8 per hour, and qualify for the earned income tax credit (welfare). Public education cost from $7000 to $, 10,000 per child, multiply that times 2 to 4 children. Add free and reduced breakfast and lunch, fee medical, food stamps, housing subsidies. Harvard Univ. put the cost of public benefits at over $70 billion annually.

  • Myth #3:  Without illegal alien farm labor, a head of lettuce would cost you $3.

It already cost you over $3. You make a down payment at the grocery store.  Government finances the other $2. Healthcare, education, food stamps, subsidized housing, criminal justice cost, etc. Farmers and Corporate America get cheap labor while you and I pay billions in social and economic cost.

  • Myth #4:  Most illegal aliens come here only to seek work and are law-abiding people.

Los Angeles, as of Jan. 2004, 95 percent of all outstanding warrants for homicide (about 1500) target illegal aliens.  66 percent of all fugitive felony warrants are for illegal aliens. Largest and most violent gangs are made up of illegal aliens, the MS-13 gang (30,000 strong, in over 33 major cities) most violent and ruthless gang ever known. The 18th street gang in L.A. is 20,000 strong made up of illegal aliens.

  • Myth #5:  It is the Federal Government’s responsibility to enforce all immigration laws.

1996 Immigration Control Act made it clear local law enforcement could enforce immigration law.

Muehler v Mena: a 9-0 Landmark Supreme Court Decision (April 1st), Stated the officers didn’t need to have reasonable suspicion.  The Court held that asking questions about immigration status was ok and yes the law does allow local law enforcement the ability to arrest.

Any decision by law enforcement not to enforce immigration laws is a political decision by politicians and local police chiefs, not a lack of authority.

A recent memo by the U.S. Department of Justice makes it clear local law enforcement can enforce immigration laws.

Every Arizonan who watches local television news knows aliens likely kill more people per year than the 1,100-plus who perished in Katrina’s waters.

As slow as the response was to Katrina disaster, they did respond. Yet we observe the disaster on our border and get little response from Washington.

Freedom and security are neither cheap nor easy. They are, quite simply, needed to ensure this country remains free and prospers. The alternative is dyer.

It seems the debate is heating up in Washington. Lawmakers and leading immigration reform advocates at both the federal and state level have put forward numerous proposals to make our borders more secure, reduce crime in our cities and reduce the amount of taxpayer money spent on services to illegal aliens.

With inertia setting in at the federal level, it is time for individual states to act also. The states must partner with the feds on this issue.

So next legislative session, legislative Republicans will be busy pursuing a common-sense strategy to cut down on the number of illegal aliens allowed to roam our neighborhoods and terrorize out citizens.

New technology married with old-fashioned techniques can go a long way securing our borders.

The comprehensive strategy will include:    

  • A proposal to install proven sophisticated radar system coupled with a far-ranging camera along the border that is capable of detecting people and vehicles traveling through the expansive desert.
  • A voter initiative to build a wall along portions of the border to ensure no large drug and human smuggling operations penetrate our porous border.
  • Another voter initiative to assess a new tax on wire transfers sent out of the country. Since few illegal aliens pay taxes on their wages, an 8-percent tax would be Arizona’s first and only chance to tax the income and the proceeds would help cover some of the cost.     
  • Continue to cut off benefits to illegal aliens already here. While Gov. Janet Napolitano fought voter approved Prop. 200 and vetoed an effort last year to expand voter-approved Proposition 200, we can protect the taxpayer from welfare benefits given to illegals.
  • A proposal to hold employers criminally liable for knowingly hiring illegal aliens. By holding employers accountable, jobs for illegals would soon dry up as employers would not risk a sanction such as the loss of a business license for employing an illegal.

Still, some politicians don't get it, after deaths in the desert, depressed wages, billions in lost taxes and additional billions in wasted taxpayer dollars to undeserving recipients, some politicians want to pander to the pro-illegal alien lobby.

I have laid out my agenda for the next year. It is filled with real reform that can provide true savings of life and money. With the federal government taking a backseat, the state needs to step up to the plate.

If Napolitano will work with the Legislature to fight illegal immigration, together we can create a safer and more prosperous Arizona.


Home |News |State Briefs |Editorials|Letters |Key Legislation |Privacy Policy |Contact Us